Tuesday, August 24, 2010

CTA Frequency Map - Wait Time Comparisons

Jarrett Walker has expressed interest in what I am doing. He may want to link to my work. I will need to choose to suggest that he link either at PrairieStateBlue or my little used personal blog Edgewater Observer. If you have thoughts about my choice please comment. Here is my latest work. It is a comparison of different possible wait times. It has a built in legend so it should be self explanatory.

CTA Frequency Map Version 9 - Ten Minute Service Circles

(Update: Oops. I am supposed to say something like: Images derived from Data Provided by The Chicago Transit Authority.)

Here are some images of version 09. In this version I have overlaid an earlier version where line widths represent the number 0f trips a week, fatter being more trips, with the ten minute or better circles from version 08.

The 79th street bus still shows that it is the major southside east west corridor. To my lay mind it still screams BRT! I'm going to have to take a trip soon and eyeball that street fr0m end to end.

The whole system map is not as large nor clear an image as I'd like. The other images show the northside and the loop area. The loop would take special treatment for a professional version, imho.
Click the images for larger version.

Monday, August 23, 2010

CTA Frequency Map V8

(Update: Oops. I am supposed to say something like: Images derived from Data Provided by The Chicago Transit Authority.)

I'm using this space as a bit of a shared workspace. So forgive the lack of relevance to the normal postings to this blog.

CTA Frequency v8 - Frequency Via Stops

Click to enlarge.

This is a work in porgress. This particular version is more a proof of concept. Here is what Mr. Walker had to say about my previous version:

Jeff. Thanks! I object, though, to using trips/day as a proxy for frequency, because lines with really intense peak service can have lots of trips/day even with little or no all-day service. . If the point of a frequency map is to show people the network they can travel on without waiting long, it needs to be based on actual midday headway. Cheers, Jarrett

So I asked for some help in coming up with "actual midday headway" thusly:

So if I am to do a midday headway map, I suppose counting the number of trips that leave between 11:30am and 12:30pm would not do because they might send out a bunch of drivers at 11:35 all together and then no more until 12:50 when another bunch might be sent out? So is actual midday headway the time between the first trip nearest noon and the one after that? Forgive my ignorance, this is not an area of expertise, but what is a good mechanism for measuring "midday headway?" What would be a good method of calculation?

To which he replied:

Jeff. You're right, it's tricky!

You have to return to the spirit of Frequent service, and the wholereason that we're mapping it. We want people to see where they can travel ALL DAY without waiting very long.

So the real question is: "What is the longest scheduled gap between consecutive buses anytime during the midday?" The point of frequent service is that it's a guarantee, not an average., That means we are mapping the worst case, not the average case.


While working with the previous version I learned that "Shapes" provided by the CTA were not properties of "Routes" but rather "Trips." In producing this map I further came to realize that "frequencies," or goal here, is also not a property of Routes nor Trips, but rather a property of "Stops".

So using the largest table provided by the CTA, the "Stop Times" table of over two milion separate records, I created a new table that not only provided the time of arrival at each stop but also the time of the previous arrival at that stop. I then calculated the greatest time difference between arrivals between seven AM and seven PM for each stop. I then drew a circle for each stop with larger circles meaning more frequency, or less maximum times between stops. The variance in circle sizes above represent a range of maximum scheduled wait time from seven or eight minutes to thirty or more minutes. Remember that's worse case scenario. I used the same color scheme from the previous map, red and orange buses, green for el/subway and blue for express bus service.

There is a ton of possible tweaking. This is a work in progress. Be patient. I'm trying to be frequent in my updates.